Recap Dinner Volnay - Pommard

by Edouard Bourgeois
June 8, 2022

So, is Volnay indeed a lighter version of its neighbor Pommard, known for its rustic edges and powerful structure?

Tuesday’s dinner at Winner may have provided some answer to that question. Ultimately, defining each village’s wine style in broad strokes seems pointless. It is no secret that each commune offers a wide diversity of styles depending on their specific climat, winemaking apart.

A special kudos to Chef Daniel Eddy who once again prepared an impeccable menu, featuring his signature roasted chicken and one of the best bread in New York.

Below are my tasting notes:

1st course

Domaine Clos de la Chapelle Volnay 1er Cru En Carelle 2018

Created 150 years ago, the domaine has been recently purchased by American Burgundy lover Mark O’Connell. “En Carelle” is in fact in the climat “Carelle sous la Chapelle” which, as the name indicates is located right below the 16th century chapel. Carelle was already designated “Tete de Cuvée”, the highest classification by Dr. Jules Lavalle in 1855. In a recent exchange with Mark, he explained to me that he preferred to change the label to “En Carelle” instead of Carelle sous la Chapelle” to avoid confusion with their flagship cuvee “Clos de la Chapelle”.

The wine provided an excellent start for the dinner, with fresh aromas of small, concentrated black fruits, certainly a signature of the heatwave from the 2018 summer.

Domaine de la Pousse d’Or Volnay 1er Cru Clos de la Bousse d’Or 2018

Great showing here. The illustrious domaine that was once part of Domaine de la Romanée Conti and Clos de Tart became an icon when in the hands of winemaker Gerard Potel. It was eventually acquired by the Landanger family in 1996 who converted the winery into a state-of-the-art facility with modern, gravity fed equipment. I found the wines from this new era to become a bit too polished for my taste, with sometimes a lack of “rusticity”. But this bottle made me (and all the guests I spoke to at dinner) very happy. A bit shy at the opening, it developed great depth and an intricate multi layered profile. A beauty.

Domaine Clos de la Chapelle Pommard 1er Cru Les Grands Epenots 2018

Back to the first producer featured here, and entering Pommard with the famous “Grands Epenots” climat, located on the northern portion of the Pommard vineyards, closer to Beaune. If there is no Grand Cru in Pommard (and in Volnay in fact) “Grands Epenots” has been in serious consideration to be elevated to that rank. The wine felt much more youthful than the first two - promise for graceful and long aging. Aeration helped but more time will be needed to tame its strong personality and let the fruit express itself more. The alcohol can be felt here.

Domaine de la Vougeraie Pommard Les Petits Noizons 2018

Created in 1999, the empire of Domaine de la Vougeraie, owned by the Boisset family, covers top vineyards. This village level “Petit Noizon”, located rather high on the slope, enjoys a southern exposure and overlooks the Premiers Crus of Pommard’s northern section. It seems that the village level ranking of this wine was felt, providing a bit less length and density than the other wines thus far. A bit thin in my opinion but a sound bottle.

2nd course

Domaine Rougeot Père et Fils Volnay 1er Cru Santenots 2017

This organic producer is an advocate of whole cluster winemaking. The bottle showed a touch of volatile acidity that seemed to linger, even after aeration. Outside of that distraction, this Volnay was elegant and pure, with high notes of fresh fruit. Quite surprising for a “Santenots”, a unique climat effectively located in Meursault, but allowed to register as Volnay when planted with Pinot Noir. Typically the Volnay Santenots is a much denser wine, quite the opposite of what one might expect of the delicate reputation of Volnay wines,

Domaine Yvon Clerget Pommard 1er Cru Les Rugiens 2017

For these Pressoir dinners, I usually start by opening most if not all the wines right before starting the dinner (depending on the age of the wines presented). For this Volnay-Pommard event, I opened all the bottles at around 6pm. First, I just smell each one without tasting them, which I do later in the evening. When I put my nose on this “Rugiens”, it was the most expressive wine. The palate later confirmed the strong personality of this excellent climat. To those who think of Pommard for its flesh and grandiose stature, this is the perfect example. The iron rich clay soils of “Rugiens”, perched over 300 meters on the hill, give this bloody aromatic characteristic to the wine. One of the wines of the night for sure.

3rd course

Domaine Nicolas Rossignol Volnay 1er Cru Chevret 2011

This wine reminded me once again that “Nico” Rossignol does very well in cool vintages. 2011 was far from easy. The rot pressure in the vineyard forced producers to meticulously sort the harvest. If the signature green notes of the vintage could be felt at first, they quickly vanish to let the fruit shine and deliver a very pretty wine. Located right under the magnificent “Cailleret” climat, “Chevret” is usually a delicate wine.

Domaine Pierre Morey Pommard 1er Cru Les Grands Epenots 2011

Pierre Morey, and now his daughter Anne, are certainly known for their superior white wines, but this Pommard was excellent. Biodynamic and fully destemmed, this wine also dodged the unappealing vegetal notes one expects from the vintage. A bit more earthiness in this “Grands Epenots” compared to the one from Domaine Clos de La Chapelle tasted earlier.

Benjamin Leroux Volnay 1er Cru Clos de la Cave des Ducs 2010

Ben Leroux’s ability to make really fine wines, even from modest appellations and in both colors makes him quite a prodigy. The young man runs a 28-hectare operation, 8 of which are vineyards he owns, the rest being purchased from trusted growers.  The Clos de la Cave des Ducs is located just outside of the village of Volnay and often seem overlooked. A bit shy at first, the wine quickly gained some weight and confidence. Excellent mouthfeel, full and rounded with juicy, sweet cherry.

Nicolas Rossignol Pommard 1er Cru Les Fremiers 2010

Nico Rossignol likes to show that Pommard can be elegant and not necessarily this powerhouse tasters may expect. Note: the climat “Fremiers” has the particularity of being in both Pommard and Volnay. In the latter, it is spelled “Fremiets”. This was a great showing with plenty of violet aromas and earthiness.

4th course

Bouchard Pere Fils Volnay 1er Cru Les Caillerets Ancienne Cuvee Carnot 1999

I always like to finish these dinners on a high note and this wine really put a smile on everyone’s face. “Cailleret” is a magnificent site and among the best Premiers Crus of Volnay, perfectly located mid-slope, with many small rocks that add a lift of minerality to the wine. Once owned by the Carnot family, this plot, right below the “Clos des 60 Ouvrées”, was the first acquisition of Domaine Bouchard in 1775. The beautiful secondary notes here were truly delectable. Unlike some of the younger wines of the previous flights, this Volnay was in full bloom, exploding with violet, truffle and juicy small red berries. Great bottle.

Domaine de Montille Pommard 1er Cru Les Pezerolles 1999

The heavyweight champion of the night. 1999 is a superb vintage all along the Cote d’Or but it performed particularly well in the Cote de Beaune, where a bit less rain fell. Sometimes compared to 2017 because of the generous quantity produced, 1999 is marked by a little more concentration which today is rewarding those who waited to open their bottles. Once again here, just like with the “Rugiens”, this “Pezerolles” had an iron rich aromatic profile and the power of the wine stretched its wings in a lingering finish.